Update: An Alternative To The Tacy Boot

A couple of weeks back, I shared with you how I was obsessed with Isabel Marant's Tacy boot (here),  but because of the hefty price tag, they would not be joining my wardrobe and I was on the search for a boot that was similar and  possessed the same amount edginess.  It was last week when I came across these two options:

Now the only questions is which one do I choose???